Why “A” Players Hire “A” Players—And “B” Players Don’t

Estimated Reading Time: 5 minutes

The Leadership Trap No One Talks About

One of the most overlooked threats to organizational growth is not poor strategy, lack of innovation, or even customer churn. It’s this: when the wrong people start hiring the wrong people.

In every business, especially in leadership roles, who you hire determines what you build. And if you’ve ever heard the expression “A players hire A players, B players hire C players,” you already understand the dangerous domino effect this creates.

What Does It Mean?

• A players are high performers. They’re confident, skilled, and driven. They’re not intimidated by others’ strengths—in fact, they seek out the best people to grow the team.
• B players are competent but cautious. Often insecure about their own abilities, they avoid hiring people who could outshine them.
• C players are underperformers—and if B players hire them, the result is a downward spiral in talent, performance, and culture.

Why It Matters for Leaders

As a business leader or manager, your hiring decisions define your legacy. When A players fill your leadership team, they raise the bar across departments. Innovation grows. Accountability becomes the norm. And your culture evolves into one of excellence.

But when you tolerate B-level hiring practices, even unintentionally, you lower standards. Mediocrity becomes the default. Energy drops. Vision fades.

Here’s the kicker: people rarely hire “down” on purpose. They do it out of fear—fear of being replaced, of being challenged, of having to adapt. That fear is invisible poison for leadership growth.

Real Example: The Silent Decline

A mid-sized tech company we recently worked with through the M360 Leadership Process had a subtle but significant performance issue.

On the surface, the business was stable. But under the hood, mid-level managers were hiring people just competent enough not to shake things up. Why? Because those managers hadn’t been coached to lead with confidence, and saw high performers as a threat.

Once we integrated the Leadership, Productivity & Results coaching program, things began to shift. Managers got the tools to lead from strength instead of fear, and the ripple effect was immediate—hiring quality improved, collaboration deepened, and retention climbed.

This shift was accelerated with the help of M360+, our leadership app. The habit tracker feature helped those same managers develop new reflexes—like weekly self-audits, feedback loops, and more courageous delegation.

Signs You Might Be Stuck in the “B Hires C” Cycle

• ✅ Do you see patterns of underperformance that seem to replicate?
• ✅ Are some leaders reluctant to delegate or develop successors?
• ✅ Are you hiring people who are “safe,” instead of people who challenge the status quo?

If yes, it may be time to re-evaluate your leadership ecosystem.

What A-Level Hiring Looks Like

• ✅ A players welcome feedback and expect others to bring ideas.
• ✅ They recruit top talent even if that means reshaping their team.
• ✅ They invest in coaching—for themselves and their people.
• ✅ They use tools like M360+ to reflect, grow, and measure what matters.

The best leaders don’t build kingdoms—they build legacies. They know their job is not to be the best at everything, but to attract and grow people who are.

3 Actions to Take Right Now

1. Audit your last 3 hires. Did you choose them because they made you comfortable or because they raised the bar?
2. Start using the M360+ habit tracker to track your leadership decisions—especially hiring and delegation patterns.
3. Enroll your management team in the “Leadership, Productivity & Results” program to reset the mindset across your organization.

Final Thought

A players don’t fear excellence—they build it.

If you want your company to scale with resilience, speed, and innovation, surround yourself with the best. Then empower them to do the same. That’s how you build an A-level culture—one hire at a time.